This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

By Antonio Neves

The short answer

Everything takes longer than you think because you guess how long the task you picture will take, not the task you'll actually do. You picture the main part and skip the setup, the waiting, the interruptions and all the small steps in between. Researchers call this the planning fallacy. To plan for it, list the steps before you guess, check the guess against the last time you did something like it, add time for the stuff between the steps, and plan today around 3 priorities instead of everything. At night, write down how long things really took, so tomorrow's guess starts from real numbers.

You block 30 minutes to send an invoice. Then you can't find last month's version. The client's address changed. The PDF won't attach. Somebody pings you with a quick question that isn't quick. It's 11:15, the invoice still isn't sent, and the rest of the morning's plan is already gone.

And it's not only the small stuff. In a 1994 study, Roger Buehler, Dale Griffin and Michael Ross asked honors students how long their thesis would take. Their best guess averaged about 34 days. It actually took 55.5. Only about 30% finished by their own best guess, and fewer than half finished by their worst case guess. Their worst case guess.

Douglas Hofstadter put it this way in his 1979 book Gödel, Escher, Bach: "It always takes longer than you expect, even when you take into account Hofstadter's Law." It's a joke, kind of. It's also pretty accurate.

Why tasks take longer than you think

When you guess how long something will take, you picture the main part. Writing the email. Painting the wall. Building the slides. You don't picture finding the file, waiting on the reply, taping off the trim, or the few minutes it takes to get your head back after a ping.

Justin Kruger and Matt Evans at the University of Illinois tested what happens when you make people picture the rest. Their 2004 paper has a great title: "If you don't want to be late, enumerate." People who first listed the individual steps of a task, like italicizing, punctuating and adding special characters when formatting a document, guessed it would take longer and were less likely to underestimate it.

There's a catch. A later set of studies led by Johanna Peetz, with Buehler as a coauthor, tried the same move on predicting how much money people would spend. Listing the details made every guess bigger. When people were guessing too low, that fixed it. When they were already about right, it pushed them too high. Their phrase for it: "bigger, not necessarily better." So listing the steps is half the move. The other half is checking against what really happened the last time.

Where this comes from for me

There's a lesson from my journalism days that fits here: whatever you think the story is going into reporting it, odds are that's not the story. Tasks work kind of the same way. Whatever you think the task is going in, odds are it's bigger than that, and the part you didn't picture is where the extra time comes from.

My family lost our home in the 2025 Los Angeles wildfires. Every morning after, I asked one question: What will make today a success? Not the year, not the month, not the week. Just this day.

The 1-Day Method grew out of that question. When your guesses run long, and some of them will, today's answer decides which things get the time you've actually got.

Want this on paper? The free 1-Day Method Starter Kit has the daily question, room for your 3 priorities, the five daily acts and a spot for end of day wins. Print it and write tomorrow's 3 on it with a time guess next to each one.

How to plan for things taking longer than you think

1. List the steps before you guess

Before you put a time on anything, write out the steps. Not a project plan. Just the pieces, fast. "Send the invoice" becomes: find last month's, update the hours, check the address, export the PDF, write the email, send. Six steps. That's the Kruger and Evans move, and seeing six steps on paper makes 15 minutes look a little silly.

Keep it quick, and do it for your 3 priorities, not for every line on your list.

2. Check the guess against the last time

Then ask yourself: the last time I did something like this, how long did it actually take? Not how long it should have taken. How long it took.

Listing the steps pushes your guess up, which is what the Peetz studies found. Your own history tells you whether it went up enough, or too much.

3. Add time for the stuff between the steps

Setup. Looking for the thing. Waiting on somebody. Getting back on track after an interruption. None of that shows up when you picture the task, and all of it takes time.

Interruptions are sneaky about it. In a 2008 study, Gloria Mark at UC Irvine and her colleagues found that people who got interrupted while answering email finished in less time, with no drop in quality. They worked faster to make up for it, and reported more stress, frustration and time pressure. So an interruption doesn't always show up as a late finish. Sometimes it shows up as you, rushing. If your day is full of switching, How to Stop Multitasking covers that part.

A couple of simple rules help. If a task depends on another person, add time for waiting on them. If it involves a file you haven't opened in a month, add 10 minutes for finding it.

4. Plan today around 3 priorities, not 12

If every guess on your list runs long, a list of 12 things might really be a list of 7, plus five things that roll to tomorrow and leave you feeling behind.

So answer the question first: What will make today a success? Then pick 3 priorities and write your padded guess next to each one. If those 3 already fill the day, the day is full. Everything else waits on the master list, the way it works in How to Make a To Do List You'll Actually Finish. When something still has to go, use the waiting test from Too Much to Do and Not Enough Time?: what actually happens if this waits until tomorrow?

5. At night, write down how long it actually took

Next to each thing you finished, write the real time. "Invoice: 40 minutes." "Slides: 2 hours, guessed 1." It takes a minute. A couple of weeks of that and you've got your own numbers, and step 2 gets a lot easier.

Put it right next to your wins for the day. The 2 minute version of that is in How to Track Daily Wins.

How much extra time should you add?

The research doesn't hand you a number. A simple place to start: add half again to your guess, so 30 minutes becomes 45 and 2 hours becomes 3. Then let step 5 replace that rule with your own numbers after a couple of weeks.

If anything, start generous. In the thesis study, even the worst case guesses ran short more than half the time.

What if the task really is quick?

Some things really do take 5 minutes. That's the other side of the Peetz finding: breaking down a guess that was already right can push it too high. If you've done something a hundred times and it always takes 5 minutes, believe the hundred times. Save the padding for the stuff you do once a month, the stuff that depends on other people, and anything new.

FAQ

Why does everything take longer than you think?

When you guess how long something will take, you picture the main part of the task and skip the setup, the waiting, the interruptions and the small steps in between. Psychologists call this the planning fallacy. In one well known study, honors students guessed their thesis would take about 34 days. It took 55.5 on average.

What is the planning fallacy?

The planning fallacy is the tendency to underestimate how long your own tasks will take. In a 1994 study by Roger Buehler, Dale Griffin and Michael Ross, only about 30% of honors students finished their thesis by their own best estimate, and fewer than half finished by their worst case guess.

How do you estimate how long a task will take?

List the steps before you guess, then check the guess against how long something similar took the last time. Add time for the stuff between the steps, like setup, waiting on other people and getting back on track after interruptions. At night, write down how long things actually took so your next guess starts from real numbers.

How much buffer time should I add to a task?

The research doesn't give one number. A simple starting point is to add half again to your guess, so 30 minutes becomes 45. After a couple of weeks of writing down how long things really took, use your own numbers instead. If you've done a task many times and it always takes 5 minutes, trust that.

What is Hofstadter's Law?

Hofstadter's Law comes from Douglas Hofstadter's 1979 book Gödel, Escher, Bach: "It always takes longer than you expect, even when you take into account Hofstadter's Law." It's half a joke, but it describes the planning fallacy pretty well.

Put your guesses on the page

The 1-Day Method Planner is the paper version of the question I asked every morning after the fire. Each day has room for your answer, the Essential 3, up to five focused tasks, the Top 5 and your wins. That's steps 4 and 5 of this post on one page: the 3 things that get the day's time, picked in the morning, and how long things really took, written next to your wins at night. The page stops at five focused tasks after the 3, so a 12 item day doesn't fit on it in the first place. It's undated, it covers 90 days, it takes under 5 minutes a day, and it's $29.99.

The 1-Day Method book is short on purpose. It walks through the question, the Essential 3 and the Top 5.

Not ready to buy anything? Grab the free Starter Kit and write tomorrow's 3 on it with a padded time next to each one.

Antonio Neves is an author, keynote speaker, and former journalist for NBC, PBS, and MTV Networks. He's delivered more than 400 keynotes for companies like Google, McDonald's, and Visa. After his family lost their home in the 2025 Los Angeles wildfires, he created The 1-Day Method to rebuild his life one day at a time.